21 August 2015

Marriage Confusion over William Scarbrough

WILLIAM SCARBROUGH



Concerning Thomas and Jane's eldest son, William, two parish records exist for a marriage, one to a Catherine Bacon in Newington St Mary in 1822

The Newington St Mary marriage


I have looked for the witnesses to this marriage and found that George Bacon was Catherine's brother. I have, to date found no record for Isabella Gregg.

The other to a Catherine Alexis in Liverpool in 1825.

The Liverpool marriage (Bishop's Transcript)

Lancashire, England, Marriages and Banns, 1754-1936
NameWilliam Scarborough
GenderMale
Event TypeMarriage
Event Date25 Apr 1825
ParishLiverpool, Lancashire
Register TypeBishop's Transcript
Household Members
NameAge
William Scarborough
Catharine Alexis

























The Liverpool marriage record states the groom's occupation as 'wine porter' thus some confusion ensued as to which bride was correct. Naturally I understood that the Newington marriage could be correct as it took place close to where William lived. All censuses stated his wife only as Catherine and that she was born in Southwark giving rise to the possibility that she was Catherine Bacon. Something niggled at me as any matches called up in ancestry hints from other trees, listed Catherine Bacon as his wife, so why was I, despite all of this evidence, convinced that everyone else was wrong and that, for some odd reason, the correct marriage was that to Catherine Alexis?

As I have said not all parish registers were uniform and some, as in the marriage in Liverpool, do not give witness information. Unfortunately these were prior to 1837 civil registration and as such no certificate can be obtained. Mostly they will not give names of parents either on marriages and sometimes just the father in births. Baptism records tend to be a bit better as they provide both parent names, in most cases.

To me there was only one way to prove this as I could find no record which mentioned his wife's name other than Catherine, since the marriage dates were 1822 & 1825 respectively, and prior to statutory registration, no marriage certificate was available, therefore, the only way I could think of to find the correct Catherine, was to find a birth record for one of the children. I chose the last child Jane, born 26 April 1852 in the registration district of St. Mary Magdalen, Bermondsey, sub district: Leather Market. Mother Catherine Scarbrough formerly Alexis. I was correct in doubting the given evidence and in heeding my own feeling that the obvious is not always correct. That in itself satisfied one curiosity, but led me to another, why were they married in Liverpool? Had he married Cath Bacon and run off with Cath Alexis, thus committing bigamy?
Had Cath Bacon died?
Is the marriage to Cath Bacon to another William Scarborough? I have, as yet found no evidence of a death or divorce for Catherine Bacon, but am still searching

Thomas' family were not the only ones to suffer tragedy. William's wife died in Guy's hospital after being horribly burned in a fire in the house. The details are below in the inquest on her death.



William's baptism record has bothered me for some time, and as I have said, I spent two and a bit years trying to find this through Ancestry. Something made me pick up an old connection to FindMyPast and on the off chance, I did a search for William's baptism. I could not believe my eyes, the first result was for William Scarbrough son to Thomas & Jane, St. Margaret, Westminster, Middlesex.

Westminster Baptisms Transcription
First name(s)
WILLIAM
Last name
SCARBOROUGH
Birth year
1804
Birth day
30
Birth month
May
Baptism year
1804
Baptism day
15
Baptism month
Jul
Parish
St Margaret, Westminster
Father's first name(s)
Thos
Mother's first name(s)
Jane
County
Middlesex
Page
215
Record set
Westminster Baptisms
Category
Birth, Marriage & Death (Parish Registers)
Subcategory
Births & baptisms
Collections from
United Kingdom

No comments:

Post a Comment